1. News & Issues
Nadra Kareem Nittle

No Black Jurors in Oscar Grant Murder Trial

By June 14, 2010

Follow me on:

It's common knowledge that in the United States those tried for crimes have the right to have cases heard by a jury of their peers. But should juries also contain the peers of victims? Such is the argument being made in the trial of Johannes Mehserle, the Bay Area Rapid Transit (BART) officer accused of killing Oscar Grant, an unarmed black man on a BART platform on New Year's Day 2009.  

The trial began last week in Los Angeles, and Grant's relatives and supporters have loudly objected to the fact that no blacks are serving on the jury in the trial of Mehserle, who is white. 

"With this jury, I'm not sure if they're going to understand what has happened to Oscar Grant," said Zeporia Smith, Grant's aunt.

The jury, selected after just one day of questioning by the prosecution and defense, includes eight women and four men. Seven of the jurors are white. Four are Hispanic, and one is of South Asian descent. Moreover, several jurors said they were friends of police officers or related to them.

"Let's look at it," said Jack Bryson, a friend of Grant. "We have mostly an all-white jury. White officer kills black man, black young man, so I mean, that's scary. It's like there's no fairness in this."

When I first learned that no blacks would serve on the jury, I was shocked as well. Unfortunately, there's a history in the U.S. of black life not being as valued as white life. Some of us have parents and grandparents who lived during the times when whites actually held lynching parties. White mobs would watch as blacks were strung up on trees, burned alive and otherwise tortured, and later send postcards of these heinous acts to friends and relatives. And during slavery, African Americans weren't considered full human beings but three-fifths the people that whites were. The legacy of this ugly history has been the countless cases in which law enforcement is accused of using excessive and deadly force against people of color with impunity.

As community activist and columnist Earl Ofari Hutcinson writes: "There have been hundreds of civilians killed by police officers in California in the past decade. Although, in many of the killings, the civilians gunned down were unarmed and not in the process of committing a crime, no officer has been charged with murder. Mehserle is the first in the past two decades to be charged."

In short, not only are there hundreds of cases involving police officers using excessive force against minority civilians, these cases overwhelmingly don't go to trial and, when they do, the officers typically aren't convicted. But Colorlines writer Julianne Hing argues that the outcome is the same even when juries do include blacks.

"The jury that acquitted the four New York police officers who killed Amadou Diallo was made up of four blacks and eight whites. ...What seems to be far more important is the race of the defendant; the defining strain in these cases is that the defendants were all white cops..."

The case of Johannes Mehserle differs from other high profile murder cases involving police officers in that the 28-year-old doesn't deny shooting and killing Grant. The defense's argument is that he did so by mistake, reaching for his gun when he meant to reach for his Taser. Of course, the victim's family doesn't buy this excuse nor do anti-police brutality activists. Also, videotaped footage reportedly records another cop on the scene using a racial slur during the incident. Surely black jurors would have a stronger reaction to such facts than non-black jurors. But let's just hope that in this case the jurors look beyond race and value the human life that was taken away and the family members still grieving the loss, as they would if Oscar Grant had been a young white father rather than a young black one.


July 5, 2010 at 6:16 pm
(1) mack says:

why have we been treated so inhumainly,,it was neccessary in order to steal your inheritance,you have been robbed of your posessions,the earth itself belongs to the black race,we were here first,we civilized the world,we even civilized these people,they attacked us from the rear,they knew that we cherished life so much that war was outlawed,yes satin has been here for a long long time

July 9, 2010 at 6:12 pm
(2) Tom says:

I find it disheartening that it is automatically assumed by many in the African-American community that white jurors will not examine the facts of a case in an unbiased manner. That is a racist presumption if ever there was one.

July 9, 2010 at 6:29 pm
(3) Soldier says:

It works both ways, I’m sure if there was a black person on the jury you could turn this around and say they will try to get this cop executed even if they ignored the facts. Now me personally, I know nothing about this situation. I’m hearing its an accident but how does this happen by accident?

How does one get a gun confused with a stun gun? Are they feelings different to a stun gun? I doubt their the same exact shape, and if they are then what idiot made them completely alike?

July 10, 2010 at 9:07 pm
(4) Mark says:

To Mack:

The only thing that made a lick of sense in your post is that “satin has been here a long time”.

So have silk & cotton.

January 15, 2011 at 1:28 am
(5) Rachel says:

Interesting… I love learning new things & seeing things from many different views. This is a very interesting…

January 12, 2012 at 10:41 pm
(6) Nick Harris says:

I was a juror in a trial that was deadlocked. A young black man was almost sent to jail for really a small crime that the state could not prove it’s case. The jury vote was 11 to 1 that he was guilty. I was the desenting vote, so the judge dismissed the jury. After that we learned all the facts of the defendent, and half of the jurors told me that they were glad that I was strong and did not give in. I actually felt that I was with a lynch mob in the jury room. Trial by peers my ass!

Leave a Comment

Line and paragraph breaks are automatic. Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title="">, <b>, <i>, <strike>
  1. About.com
  2. News & Issues
  3. Race Relations

©2014 About.com. All rights reserved.